Office 365 banned in German schools
In the past, German schools were able to make use of the 'German cloud' offered by Microsoft until mid of 2018. Then Microsoft ceased to offer a data trustee model that met German requirements in regards to privacy protection.
More and more schools have asked the Hessian department of Data Protection and Freedom of Information whether they were allowed to use the European cloud instead.
Now the Hessian commissioner of Data Protection and Freedom of Information has issued a statement declaring that using the European cloud is illegal for German schools. According to the statement, Microsoft's European cloud does not satisfy German privacy regulations for use in schools.
Two privacy concerns
Two issues were criticized specifically:
- American authorities can access data stored in the European cloud without the German government having control over this.
- In Office 365 and Windows 10 lots of telemetry data is gathered and transmitted to Microsoft without Microsoft giving satisfying information about what is logged and transferred.
Protecting children's data
For the Hessian commission of Data Protection and Freedom of Information the protection of children's data comes first:
"The critical aspect is if a school as a public institution may store personal data (of children) in a (European) cloud, which, for instance, is open to access from US-American authorities. Public institutions in Germany have a particular responsibility in regards to permissibility and transparency of the processing of personal data."
In consequence, the data commissioner reasons that the data processing by Microsoft is illegal. In addition, this can not be helped by asking parents for consent to data processing. This would not satisfy the particular protection rights of children in regards to article 8 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
The Hessian commissioner also states that
"What is true for Microsoft is also true for the Google and Apple cloud solutions. The cloud solutions of these providers have so far not been transparent and comprehensibly set out. Therefore, it is also true that for schools the privacy-compliant use is currently not possible."
Consequences for German schools
The privacy concern is so severe that German schools must no longer use Office 365. However, lots of schools, particularly trade schools, use Office 365 to prepare students for office work with Word, Excel etc. Instead of Office 365, these schools must now use on-premise licenses on local systems.
Schools that only use Office 365 for email also have the option to switch to a secure email service such as Tutanota. Here all data is stored encrypted on German servers, respecting the strict German privacy protection laws, in full compliance with the GDPR.
Secure groupware suite is planned
In the future, we plan to extend our secure email service that already incorporates an address book and a calendar - everything encrypted by default - into a fully encrypted Groupware Suite.
tl:dr: While the Office 365 case in Germany is mostly about pressuring Microsoft into adhering to German privacy regulations rather than switching services, it would be much preferred to have a true alternative to Microsoft, Google and Apple. That's what Tutanota is building right now. Started with secure emails, Tutanota today also offers an encrypted address book, an encrypted calendar, and the encrypted contact form Secure Connect. Many more features are planned, and we estimate that in a few more years, we can offer an encrypted Groupware Suite with maximum respect of user privacy.